|
|
|
Louisiana Cellular Reviews
Mountain Wireless presents an opinionated review of wireless
and cellular phone services in Louisiana.
This is information gained from personal
experience, user interviews, press
releases,
advertising material, newsgroups and
wireless
web sites.For Ratings of these carriers, Click Here.
ALLTEL
The Alltel network in this state has been
purchased by Verizon Wireless. Parts of the Alltel network in other states
have been sold to Verizon and AT&T as
well as ATN who continues to operate under the Alltel
name.
AT&T Review
AT&T
AT&T has a large GSM network, but in
the west, have a lot less developed spectrum
than in the rest of the country. That has
improved with AT&T's acquisition of Alltel
Wireless in 76 markets in the western US.
They converted most former Alltel sites to
3G GSM. Some ex-Alltel customers noticed
significant changes in coverage with the
loss of CDMA roaming partners. With GSM technology,
AT&T roams more readily internationally,
but there are areas in the US with no GSM
coverage. AT&T's takeover of other cellular
networks has improved their service in some
areas already, including Alaska. AT&T
offers a large selection of GSM phones including
the Apple iPhone. Parts of what was the old
AT&T Wireless network in the interior
west is still not among the best. They still
suffer from some coverage 'holes', but they
are updating some of these areas. Most improvements
will be made in the new markets and are increasing
data capacity instead of adding cell sites
in older areas. They have added "4G"
coverage in a handful of markets and will
upgrade most of the network in the near future.
In several markets where AT&T operates
at 1900 MHz only, we have been disappointed, but not all
AT&T 1900 MHz-only markets are equal.
AT&T offers a variety of plans including
Unlimited minutes and services, and 'calling
circle' plans. They have extensive data coverage.
One of their greatest assets is also their
worst problem: the overwhelming success of
the Apple iPhone on the AT&T network.
It has overloaded their system resulting
in dropped calls, interrupted data and slower
service. This situation is improving with
the defection of some iPhone users.
Pros: AT&T has a large network and covers
much of the nation, usage is transparent
whether on- or off-network, good digital
and data services, good national plans, "Rollover"
for those who can use it, "Unlimited"
calling plans available, a very good selection
of phones. Improvements in coverage have
been substantial in some areas, lacking in
others. Excellent international roaming capabilities,
and AT&T will now supply the unlock code
for all phones, except the iPhone, after
3 to 10 months. Additions of Alltel, Unicel
and Centennial network purchases give AT&T
substantial rural coverage improvements.
Cons: AT&T plans aren't as generous as
some, customers can only access GSM networks
which are not as universally available in
the US as CDMA, customer service varies from
above to below average, some markets have
a large number of dropped calls caused by
large data users. Some customers who have
been transferred from other networks have
noticed substantial changes in coverage,
mostly while roaming.
Get Web-Only Discounts on Wireless from AT&T
Get Discount AT&T GoPhone Refills
BROADPOINT
Primarily offering service to people and
businesses who operate in the Gulf of Mexico,
Broadpoint operates a cellular network with
coverage over 100,000 miles of the Gulf with
voice, text and data services. Being a subscriber
of Broadpoint is normally a cheaper option
than using the roaming options of other carriers.
They offer GSM service with continuous on-water
coverage along the coast and good roaming
capabilities when you travel throughout the
mainland US. Broadpoint is owned by Cellular One (MTPCS) which facilitates Broadpoint's US roaming.
Plans are expensive and they only offer one
phone model for voice communications. They
offer a large number of professional data
and communication services, including satellite
communications geared to petroleum installations.
Broadpoint operates what was formerly the
Petrocom network in the Gulf.
CELLULAR ONE (MTPCS)
"MTPCS" is the corporate name of
this Cellular One which is made up several
former networks including Chinook Wireless
in Montana and Wyoming, Centennial Wireless
in the South and parts of AT&T in Texas.
They have good GSM coverage with some unserved
areas in Montana and Wyoming, and very good
coverage in rural areas of Louisiana, Oklahoma
and Texas. They have been adding new cell
sites and bringing new GSM service to many
rural areas. They offer all the digital goodies
and have a good selection of phones including
Smart phones and home phone service. They
now have a number of local stores for even
more personal service. They have many choices
of plans that are little more generous than
average. They offer economical "Statewide"
plans as well as several levels of National
and Unlimited plans. They have very reasonable
plans for local wireless Internet access.
They offer a number of economical add-ons
including 'My Circle', International Calling,
5pm Nights & Weekends and Free Incoming
Calls. and they support Lifeline plans.
Pros: While they offer service over several
states, their are able to offer fairly Local-oriented
customer service, especially at their own
retail stores. They offer a variety of reasonably-priced
plans including various options of Statewide,
National and Unlimited plans.
Cons: Their MT/WY coverage is weak away from
main roads and outside of populated areas,
in the south you may experience interrupted
service as you roam across different networks.
Cellular One/MTPCS Montana/Wyoming Coverage
Maps
CENTENNIAL WIRELESS
Centennial has been purchased by AT&T. Some Centennial customers in Louisiana
and Mississippi have been transferred to
Verizon Wireless, the affected areas are listed on the Centennial Coverage page. Other customers in Louisiana, Oklahoma
and Texas have been transferred to Cellular One. Virtually all customers and network facilities
have been transferred and most customers
have experienced noticeable improvements.
|
|
Metro PCS Pros & Cons
METROPCS
MetroPCS is a 'flat rate' CDMA carrier available
in 14 US metro areas. They offer unlimited
minute wireless coverage for one price including
Text Messaging, but their own coverage area
is limited. They have roaming agreements which provide
Unlimited service in most other areas of
the country. For the price, it may work well for you,
or your family. Plans start at $40 per month
and Family plans are cheaper than average.
All plans include Unlimited Web access. Metro
PCS allows "unlocked" CDMA phones
from other sources to be activated on their
network. They have some useful options like fixed-rate
calling to Mexico and a Group Ring for families.
They have a good selection of phones including
Smart phones. They are slowly expanding 4G
coverage. Metro will accept phones from other
CDMA carriers. We have never been able to
talk to a MetroPCS customer service representative.
They have tried to configure their auto-response
features to address customer questions and
problems which we have found lacking. Metro
claims this is "to keep costs low",
but we don't like having the option at all.
Pros: Talk as much as you want, and they
have all the digital features, off-network
roaming is available, most of it unlimited,
they have an all-3G/4G network.
Cons: You must pre-pay, roaming is not available outside the US. With this type of non-contract carrier phone
prices are higher. They are still growing
so there are still some areas with poor coverage.
Many features are not included in the cheapest
plans, customer service rarely involves a
human to speak with, and we have found the
agents at many MetroPCS stores are often
unable to help with our inquiries.
Get Discounts on Metro PCS
NEXTEL
Nextel is a of part Sprint and in some offers,
Sprint hides Nextel's features. The combo
has allowed the two networks to start sharing
cell sites to improve coverage. Nextel's
spectrum is made up from a bunch of 2-way
radio channels, and they suffer from marginal
audio in some markets. Their coverage and
quality varies by market. They cover urban
areas and some interstates, but there is
little roaming elsewhere in the state. They
have an efficient 'walkie-talkie' feature
which is handy for businesses and families who want to contact
each other as quickly as possible. Some of their plans aren't very competitive,
but they do offer free incoming calls. They
use 850 MHz so they have a strong signal
in most areas. Sprint has announced they
are not improving or expanding the Nextel
network. and will turn off the current iDEN
service in 2013 and use the 800 MHz channels
for Sprint CDMA service. Some Boost Mobile
handsets use the Nextel network and is a
good option for Unlimited Voice and Text.
For as long as it lasts, Nextel offers international
roaming in a handful of other countries in
North and South America, including Mexico,
some with Free Internet access.
Pros: The Direct Connect is a handy 'walkie-talkie'
service, they have robust coverage within
their service area.
Cons: Some markets have poor audio, they
also have coverage limits and very limited
roaming, most of their phones are big and
lack variety. Nextel does not have fast broadband
features, neither the network nor the coverage
are being upgraded. Sprint has not treated
Nextel customers as well as those using the
Sprint network. Many new Nextel customers
are being giving Sprint-branded phones, so
you may not be using the network you think
you are. The Nextel network will be converted
to CDMA by 2013.
Get Online Discounts on Nextel Phones
PACE CELLULAR
Pace is the wireless division of the Kaplan
Telephone Company of south Louisiana. They offer both Local and National Plans.
The Local plans offer lots of minutes for
the money but only in a small area, mostly
the Vermilion Parish. Some of their National
plans are reasonable, others can be expensive.
They have several small, annoying fees for
features like Caller ID and for calling land
line phones. They offer many models of GSM
phones, Smart Phones and air cards, and offer
lots of data features.
SPRINT
Sprint has a national, feature-rich digital
network. Their coverage is a little "fragile",
but where it's good, it's very good. Sprint
has a good selection of phones. Their plans
include the ability to roam on other systems.
They offer an inexpensive "basic"
plan for only $30 per month. They also offer
a few Unlimited plans with lots of features
included. Sprint has added service by taking
over parts of some carriers' networks, and
"sharing" spectrum with others.
Sprint merged with Nextel which has created some beneficial network
configurations, including sharing of cell
sites. Sprint phones normally prefer the
network which, where available, gives Sprint
customers the best data throughput. Some
Sprint phones have the ability to force the
phone to "Roam Only", helping you
use the strongest network, however there
is a limit to how much roaming you can do,
generally 50%. Also, newer phones lack that
feature. Sprint does not offer their own
branded prepaid service but owns Boost Mobile
and Virgin Mobile prepaid and others. If you are considering Sprint 4G service,
keep in mind they use a completely separate
network for 4G coverage supplied in partnership
with Clear Wireless. Therefore, having good local Sprint Voice/Text
or 3G data coverage is no guarantee of adequate
4G coverage.
Pros: Sprint gives you good value for your
money, but is not necessarily the cheapest.
Sprint covers every urban area in the US,
maintains local stores, good roaming capabilities,
their digital and data features work very
well, they have a good selection of phones.
Sprint has good roaming agreements in most
areas of the country.
Cons: You might find a weak area right where
you want coverage, some of their plans are
not very competitive, customer service is a notch below average,
4G coverage uses a different frequency band
and network than other Sprint coverage, Unlimited
plans do not include unlimited usage while
roaming, except for "Simply Everything"
plans. Get Online Discounts on Sprint Phones
More Sprint Pros & Cons
T-MOBILE
T-Mobile works very well within their own
GSM service area. While they have a slight
disadvantage with their higher PCS frequency,
they make up for it with strategically-located
sites. T-Mobile doesn't serve many rural
areas, but provides coverage along most major
rural highways. They do offer coverage from
roaming partners in rural areas, and the
network is still growing, although often
they're just 'filling in' already-served
areas. They offer some handy features including
several family-friendly services with a number
of ways to control device usage. They offer
a number of plans that allow you to choose
between subsidized handsets and non-contract
pricing. Many of their phones allow "Hot
Spot" access which keeps usage costs
down. They have plans that include unlimited
voice and messaging, they offer nearly nationwide
service with both their own network and extensive
roaming agreements. T-Mobile charges extraordinarily
high roaming rates outside of the US and
much higher than average Long Distance charges
to foreign phone numbers. Expect improving
roaming capabilities with the recently failed
deal with AT&T.
Pros: Generous included-minute plans, National
and Unlimited plans, good urban coverage,
good roaming capabilities including internationally.
They offer both 3G and 4G coverage, competitive
data pricing and 'hot spot' access. They
have very good customer service and a very
good selection of phone models. They have
an excellent Prepaid plan that includes a
good amount of North American roaming.
Cons: Some weak spots, limited data bandwidth
in some areas, very high international roaming
charges. Higher speed services require the
use of higher frequency cellular bands which
may restrict coverage and data roaming capabilities.
There has been some reduction of voice and
text roaming capabilities as some old roaming
agreements expire, but we expect this to
improve shortly. Get Online-only Discounts from T-Mobile
Discount T-Mobile Prepaid Refills
TracFone Pros & Cons
TRACFONE
Tracfone isn't an actual cellular carrier
but is a major supplier of wireless phones
and offers service in most areas of the state.
They are the largest prepaid cellular company
and arrange for their phones to use whichever
wireless carrier is available in a given
geographic area. As a result, Tracfone actually
has more included roaming coverage available
than perhaps any other single company. Their
price points start below $9 a month and offer
all the advantages of prepaid services. They
also feature monthly plans and offer promotions
with bonus minutes, and plans with 365-day
expiration. Their service is mostly limited
to Voice and Text but does support data use
of some of their phones. They offer the option
of having the charges deducted from your
credit card or checking account automatically,
eliminating the need to renew on an exact
expiration date. TracFone offers Free international
calls to about 60 countries by calling a
special access number, and with their International
Neighbors features, they provide a local
number in Mexico or Canada for incoming calls
from those countries at local rates for both
callers. Tracfone offers additional plan
options, including Unlimited plans, through
NET10.
Pros: Coverage and Local service is available
virtually everywhere in the US, good price
plans with no roaming or long distance charges,
Local numbers in all markets, included Long
Distance calling to 60 countries.
Cons: They have a small selection of phones,
coverage is determined by the phone model
(CDMA or GSM) which may limit your roaming coverage or
phone selection, you can only use one of
their phones, no roaming outside the US.
Get Online Deals on TracFone
Discount TracFone Refills
VERIZON WIRELESS
Verizon has the largest network, geographically,
in the US. They have taken over a large portion
of the old Alltel network and are now dominant in rural America.
Their claim to fame is superior coverage
on their CDMA network, especially in the
west. They use PCS frequencies in a few areas,
but they have constructed those networks
well. In the few places where they don't have their
own coverage, they have roaming agreements
with other carriers, normally ones with superior
coverage. Therefore, their "National"
plans, which include almost all of the country,
are about as close to "wall-to-wall"
as you can get. Their reasonably-priced plans
have no roaming or long distance charges,
and they also throw in Unlimited Night and
Weekend minutes as well as Unlimited calls
among Verizon Wireless users both on and
off their own network (there are a few exceptions).
They offer fairly competitive prices, and
often have promotions. They also offer plans
that include Unlimited Voice and other features
at various fixed price levels. Data service
is excellent with various price plans. Verizon
forces their phone manufacturers to offer
a "standardized" user interface,
limiting menu and font variations. This could
mean the screen appearance may not be to
your liking or the fonts may be too small.
Smart and data-type phones require a per-Mb
plan. They have the largest area of 3G coverage in the US and now offer faster 4G service in many major cities and major airports
in additional markets.
Pros: Verizon has reasonably-priced plans,
"Unlimited" calling plans available,
extensive coverage, wide-ranging National
plans, excellent customer service and some
'customer-friendly' policies. With such a
large coverage area of their own, little
roaming is necessary, and their roaming partners
normally have superior coverage. They offer a large variety of phones including
the Apple iPhone
Cons: Some Verizon plans are a little more
expensive, Customer Service closes at 11pm,
but technical assistance is available 24/7.
They 'cripple' some User Interface functions
like larger fonts: make sure you can read
their submenus before buying. They require
more expensive Data plans for any data-capable
phone. Some of their data services are not
available while roaming. CDMA phones roam
in a limited number of foreign countries
but Verizon can provide a hybrid loaner phone
that will work both in the US and most foreign
countries.
Get Online Exclusive Discounts on Verizon Wireless
Get Discount Refills for Verizon Prepaid
|